Dynamic logoTHE DYNAMIC
GROUP

Guides · Updated November 2026

Screw piles vs driven piles: what's the difference?

Screw piles are steel piles with a helical plate that are wound into the ground by a torque motor on an excavator; driven piles are timber, steel or precast concrete piles hammered or vibrated in by a large piling rig. Screw piles are quiet, low-vibration, torque-verified and suit houses, decks, extensions and light commercial work on tight sites. Driven piles carry very heavy loads and are standard in commercial, marine and bridge work, but the rigs are big, noisy and expensive to mobilise, so they are rarely used for residential jobs in Melbourne. The engineer specifies which one the structure needs. The DYNAMIC Group installs screw piles and bored piers, not driven piles.

Prices on this page are indicative ranges for Victoria at the time of writing, not a quote. Based in Keilor East, Melbourne. Working across metropolitan and regional Victoria, New South Wales and South Australia.

What a driven pile is

A driven pile is a long, straight pile, usually timber, steel H-section or tube, or precast reinforced concrete, that is forced into the ground by repeated blows from a hammer or by a vibrating head. The pile displaces the soil as it goes, and it stops when it reaches a set depth or when the blows per metre, called the set, show it has reached bearing.

The rig that does this is a crane or a purpose-built piling frame with a leader to hold the pile vertical and a hydraulic or drop hammer on top. It is heavy plant that needs a flat, firm working platform, a wide access route and room to lay piles out on the ground. Driven piles are the normal choice for wharves, bridges, multi-storey buildings, industrial slabs on soft ground and anywhere very high loads have to reach deep bearing.

What a screw pile is

A screw pile is a galvanised steel shaft with one or more helical plates welded near the tip. A torque-motor drive head on an excavator winds it into the ground, and the torque needed to turn it is read against the engineer's chart to confirm it has reached its design load. There is no hammering, no spoil and no concrete. We install them in 76, 89 and 105 mm diameters for homes, extensions, decks, sheds, retaining walls, park cabins and light commercial structures across Victoria.

When driven piles are the right choice

  • Very heavy loads: multi-storey, industrial and infrastructure work where each pile carries far more than a residential helical pile is rated for.
  • Deep soft ground over a hard layer, where a long precast or steel pile driven to set is the economical way to reach it.
  • Marine and waterfront work: wharves, jetties, bridge piers and seawalls.
  • Large open sites with good access, where the rig can work efficiently and the pile count justifies bringing it in.

When screw piles are the right choice

  • Houses, extensions, decks, sheds and light commercial buildings, where the loads are within the range of 76 to 105 mm piles.
  • Tight access: our 1.8 tonne excavator fits through a gap under 750 mm wide — down the side of a house, onto a sloping block or inside an existing building — and we scale up to 20 tonne machines for large sites.
  • Reactive clay, filled or wet sites, where the pile is wound below the active zone and the torque proves it has reached bearing.
  • Established suburbs, where noise and vibration near neighbours, old houses and services matter.
  • Programme pressure: piles in the morning, frame in the afternoon.

Cost and access compared

Driven piling is a mobilisation-heavy exercise. The rig, the crane, the pile delivery and the working platform are a large fixed cost before the first pile goes in, so it only makes sense on jobs with enough piles and load to spread that cost. On a residential job a driven piling set-up would often cost more than the whole screw pile package. Screw piles are priced per pile, installed, and the machine is the same excavator that does site cuts, so a backyard job of a dozen piles is economical. On a big commercial site with heavy loads the comparison reverses and driven or bored piles usually win on cost per tonne of capacity. Our screw pile cost guide gives indicative Victorian ranges for residential work.

Noise, vibration and the neighbours

Hammer-driven piling is loud, repetitive and sends vibration through the ground for tens of metres. In a Melbourne suburb that means complaints, often a council noise condition on the permit, dilapidation surveys of neighbouring houses before work starts, and a real risk of cracking old plaster, brick fences or clay sewer pipes. Vibrated piles are quieter than hammered ones but still shake the ground. A screw pile installation sounds like an excavator idling and causes almost no vibration, which is one of the main reasons engineers specify screw piles for infill, extension and boundary work in established suburbs.

Who decides

Your structural engineer specifies the footing system from the loads, the soil report and the site. For nearly every house, extension, deck or shed in Victoria the answer will be screw piles, bored piers or a stiffened slab; driven piles belong to a different scale of project. We install screw piles and bored piers, and we do not install driven piles. If your engineer has specified driven piles for a residential job, it is worth asking whether screw piles or bored piers would do the same work, because the answer is usually yes and the saving is large.

Questions we get asked

Are screw piles as strong as driven piles?

For the structures they are specified on, yes. A screw pile is designed and torque-verified to carry the load the engineer sets, and residential helical piles are rated for the loads a house, extension or deck puts on them. A large driven pile can carry far more than a 105 mm screw pile, which is why driven piles are used for bridges and high-rise, but that extra capacity is not needed on a house.

Which is faster to install?

On a residential job, screw piles by a wide margin: a crew installs 20 to 30 piles in a day with a single excavator, and the frame can follow immediately. A driven piling rig can install piles quickly once it is set up, but the mobilisation, working platform and pile delivery add days to the programme before the first pile goes in.

Can driven piles be used in a backyard?

Rarely. The rig needs wide access and a firm, level working platform, the noise and vibration are hard on neighbours and nearby structures, and the mobilisation cost is out of proportion to a backyard job. Screw piles or bored piers do the same work from a compact excavator, which is why they are the standard footing for extensions, decks and sheds in Melbourne.